On her family's rescue ranch, Skye has a special connection with a new horse named Puzzle. Skye, Olivia, Trish and Ethan come together to form the Ponysitters' Club to help with all the animals on the ranch.

As their first community fundraiser, the Ponysitters prepare and run a successful pancake breakfast, despite all odds. Skye accidentally leaves a stall door unlatched, causing Mini the visiting miniature horse